
I was absolutely elated by the overwhelmingly positive response that my recent blog post received. The feedback and the poll results definitely proved one thing to me: I am not alone. Not only am I not completely insane for having doubts about wanting to become a doctor, but the vast majority of folks (98%, according to the poll results) have had some doubts about med school at some point in their life.
Reading all the responses to my post was an incredibly rewarding experience for me. Many people shared their own personal stories, and some also offered their advice. I feel so very fortunate to have an arena to share my thoughts, aspirations, and fears with the world.
It really got me thinking about what it means to have a blog, and especially one that is read by many people. It’s sort of like having your own set of personal therapists. I can bounce ideas off of, share my experiences with, and receive feedback from a variety of different folks. In some ways, it’s even better than a therapist I might randomly pick out of the Yellow Pages, as the readers of this blog are generally involved in the medical field, and hence can understand what I’m going through better than the “average joe.” Of course, blogging is no substitute for actual therapy. But it is an interesting complement to the typical therapy that existed prior to the advent of blogging.
Through reading the comments on my entry, I discovered some common themes in people’s stories. In doing so, it allowed me to hone in on some of the possible causes of my doubts about medicine as a career.
It seems as though being a third-year medical student provides some sort of breeding ground for doubts to thrive. After reflecting on this, I realized that this has a lot to do with my angst. Adding to this, is the fact that I worked for many years (14 to be exact) before going to med school. In fact, I had a full-time job even throughout my undergrad years. It wasn’t until med school that I gave up employment altogether. Now I’m a full-time professional student.
The problem is that the third year of med school (in the U.S.) is a limbo period. You are no longer focusing all your time on studying the basic sciences. However, you also know very little about the clinical world. While I have received much training on physical examination methods, history taking techniques, and many other clinical skills, I can honestly say that the majority of the time, I still feel like a complete idiot. I can’t consistently differentiate the various heart murmurs by auscultation. I still miss the vein many times when starting an IV. I have a hard time determining if a person has hepatomegaly. The list goes on and on, but I think you get the point.
As a student, I also have very little actual responsibility. Sure, the doctor listens when I present a patient, and takes my findings into account, but they will still usually go back and check things out for themselves. My treatment suggestions are heard, but they are still merely suggestions. The doctor who signs the orders has the ultimate say, and that’s definitely a good thing because I don’t trust my opinions very much.
As a fourth-year, you are still learning a lot, but from what I’ve seen, you have the confidence that comes with practice. And doctors are more likely to trust your findings and treatment plans.
When you take all of these factors into consideration, perhaps you can understand why the life of a third-year med student can be rough at times. When I worked at the AAMC, for example, I got paid to do tasks, and I did them all fairly well. As a third-year med student, I pay to do tasks, and I do them all fairly poorly. It’s an unnerving reversal of lifestyles.
After reading all the responses to my post, and evaluating my options, I’ve developed a rough draft of a plan for the next few years. I’m going to keep trudging along, and try to complete my M.D. degree. After I graduate, I will either apply for a psychiatry residency, apply to a clinical psychology Ph.D program, or perhaps I will open an animal rescue shelter. I really don’t know at this point. But for now, I will focus on the goal of receiving my “piece of paper” and try to develop some sort of plan along the way. I will also attempt to spend more time with my patients, and I have a feeling that in doing so, I will remember the reasons why I was initially inspired by a career in medicine.
Click Here To View the Original Post on Medscape