Are Fat Doctors Just Human?
I finally made it back to the USA. I flew out of the “airport”in Dominica on Saturday morning and arrived in Baltimore around midnight. As I walked through the airport to the baggage claim, I noticed two things right away. The first was the overabundance of food options: fried chicken, pizza, cheeseburgers, and just about anything one could imagine. In Dominica, there are very few restaurants, and certainly no McDonald’s or Taco Bell. The second thing I noticed was the preponderance of overweight people. Everywhere I looked I saw heavy people, and even some who were morbidly obese. I couldn’t help but realize the connection. Of course, I had noticed this before when I lived in the States, but the stark contrast between Dominica and the U.S. really made it stand out in my mind. In Dominica, there are overweight people, but they are a much smaller percentage of the population.
Obesity is a popular topic in the news lately, and the medical system bears much of the financial burden of America’s expanding waistlines. Most major killers in the U.S., such as Type II diabetes, high blood pressure, and coronary heart disease, can be tied to obesity.
As a physician-in-training, I’m trying to get a grip on the problem. By the time I’m practicing, I will likely have a lot of patients who are overweight. It’s important that I understand the causes of obesity and know effective ways to treat it.
Of course, I haven’t lived a completely healthy life myself. I’ve abused my body just like most people, and I’ve paid the price. Over the past few years, though, I’ve really tried to maintain a healthier lifestyle. I try to eat plenty of fruits and vegetables, and I have worked out regularly for years. I’d say that I’m in fairly good health, and my appearance reflects that. But as a future physician, do I actually have a duty to maintain a healthy lifestyle? Do all doctors have an obligation to live healthy lives and stay at an appropriate weight in order to be effective healers?
This is a very hotly debated question (as seen in the discussion following this Medscape article). I don’t have the perfect answer, but I do believe that it’s important to maintain a healthy lifestyle, and I’m also a huge proponent of maintaining a balance in life. I will definitely eat a doughnut every once in a while, and I’m already guilty of eating at McDonald’s since I’ve been back in the States. I sometimes fall behind in my exercise, and I’ve gone without good sleep some nights. But, I always return to my healthy habits, even if I do splurge every once in a while.
The question is, what about doctors who don’t adopt this philosophy? Can a patient be expected to do as you say, but not as you do? Is it fair to counsel someone on healthy habits and insist that they change their lifestyle, when you don’t hold yourself to these same standards?
As for myself, I hope to continue to live a healthy lifestyle (with my admitted lapses at times), and I hope that this will reinforce my advice to patients. On the other hand, will a patient who is struggling with their weight look at me and believe that I know what it’s like to struggle with a weight issue? Would it be easier to accept instructions from a doctor who also is overweight?
Looking forward, I hope to be able to effectively communicate with my patients and let them know that living healthily is not always easy. I give in to my cravings for peanut butter pie, and sometimes I skip my daily run and veg out with a movie instead. I don’t think that makes me a bad role model, nor will it make me a bad physician someday. I think it just makes me human. Perhaps being able to see a doctor as a human, and not just a role model, is more important than the size of the doctor’s waist.
Click Here To View the Original Post on Medscape
Comments(1)




My name is Kendra and I am a newly minted doctor about to begin my residency in Psychiatry at

